Well, looking at Captain America: Civil War (the third Captain America film, thirteenth MCU film and arguably, third Avengers movie) there are two sides to this; one is that its very much more of the same, the other that it’s a genuine attempt to put a twist on the now fairly well-worn formula. In honesty the final result lies somewhere between.
The story is two-fold as well, being the next in the direct Captain America series (after The First Avenger and Winter Soldier) it continues the story of The Winter Soldier and Hydra that was left off at the end of the preceding film.
All of this considered it certainly seems that Marvel have almost entirely given up on the idea that people would come to these films cold as there is a lot going on relating back to previous films – while this was fine for me, it certainly could be a problematic way of making movies going forward.
With all of this combined and the arrival of at least two brand new superheroes (Black Panther and Spider-Man) there is a lot going on, which explains the films two and a half hour running time.
While certainly on the long side at no point did I find Captain America: Civil War drag with a good balance between fairly earnest talky scenes and the kind of big action set pieces that are Marvel’s stock in trade.
With Joss Whedon having moved on from Marvel it seems this is, in a way, Anthony and Joe Russo’s dry run for the next Avengers films they will be directing and, if I’m honest I preferred their take on the relationships between the main characters.
Whedon’s banter-like dialogue was lightly amusing but generally ultimately empty, while here Captain America (Chris Evans) and Iron Man (Robert Downey Jr.) felt more natural… well as natural as comic book movie dialogue is ever going to be.
On top of this the new Spider-Man (Tom Holland) provided the film’s light relief in a genuinely satisfying way and in the manner the comic book version of the character is known for that has previously never quite been demonstrated on-screen.
The highlight of the film comes in the middle with the ‘Civil War’ set piece of Cap’s group of heroes facing off with Iron Man’s. While it’s certainly a lot CGI characters hitting each other, it contains some inventive new twists on the old formula.
After this we are very much more in Hydra/Winter Solider territory again and really the two stories rarely properly join together, but as a ride it all slots together enough to make it watchable as long as you don’t think too hard.
The marketing for the film hinted that the Civil War side of the story might deal with some political ideas to some degree but this isn’t really the case with it all apparently boiling down to personal issues between the characters.
This being a US election year though it could be argued that, in general terms, Tony Stark represents the Democrat view of gun control, while Steve Rogers is on the Republican end, but this would probably give too much credence to the film’s political ambitions.
In the end Captain America: Civil War was more entertaining that I had anticipated, while still being essentially more of the same from the MCU and, while all painted in very broad strokes, it seems Anthony and Joe Russo have at least found a tone that works; somewhere between flippant and melodramatic with just enough weight to make the story worth investing in (even if you do know who’s going to come out on top even before the lights go down).